New York Itinerary 4 Days: The PERFECT Guide (From a Local)

Everything You Need To Know To Plan a 4-Day Itinerary in New York City

Planning a New York itinerary and need to fill up 4 days’ worth of activities in the city? I’ve got you covered! This is the full and complete guide to planning 4 days in New York.

Welcome to the ultimate guide for planning a New York itinerary filled with 4 days of unforgettable adventures. 

Over a year ago, I made the decision to switch out the prickly cactus of Arizona for the dazzling lights of NYC. I’ve since spent 365+ days exploring everything this city has to offer. Since you’re about to make your first big trip to the city, I’m here to help you craft the perfect New York itinerary for your first visit.

This guide contains New York’s most iconic landmarks as well as cherished local treasures. It serves as your compass to navigate the essential attractions, the city’s hidden secrets, and all the culinary delights that are simply unmissable on your first trip to the Big Apple.

While you won’t have the opportunity to experience every facet of this sprawling metropolis in just 4 days (I’ve been here over a year, and I still haven’t gotten to everything on my list!), I’ll make sure you cover all the most important places. And as for anything you can’t get to during your stay, there’s always next time! 

So let’s dive into what the absolute must-see attractions are for your first 4-day trip to NYC.

🤩 Immortalize your New York City trip with the help of an NYC professional photographer.

Is This 4-Day New York City Itinerary For You?

This itinerary was written for the independent traveler who is visiting New York for the first time and wants to create a travel itinerary spanning 4 days. 

It’s for those who would rather create their own adventures than join a large, fully-structured, tightly-scheduled group. That said, this type of adventurer still loves to join the occasional intimate touring experience. Just the ones that are truly worth it and aren’t oversaturated with other tourists.

If that describes you, then this 4-day New York City itinerary was written with you in mind. 😉

Even if you’re a seasoned visitor to New York, you’ll still find value in this itinerary. You might even gain a few ideas for things you haven’t thought of before. But if you see a few holes to fill from things you’ve already done, check out my list of 72 of the best things to do in NYC at Night and my other New York Content for inspiration to fill those gaps.

Either way, you’re in for an unforgettable adventure!

How To Use This 4-Day New York City Itinerary

This New York itinerary was created with the idea that you have 4 full days to spend in the city. So that means Day 1 starts bright and early in the morning with breakfast and coffee.

To make the most of your trip to NYC, aim to arrive the evening before Day 1. Or get the earliest flight in that morning. Ideally, you’re going to start your day at 8 a.m. This makes sure you get to see and do everything you want to in this vast concrete jungle.

To give you a full 4 days in town, this also means that for this itinerary to work, you should plan to leave New York late at night on Day 4 or give yourself a 5th day for traveling home.

New York Itinerary: 4 Days At A Glance

➡️Day 1: Central Park & The Empire State Building

➡️Day 2: Saint Patrick’s Cathedral & Broadway

➡️Day 3: Financial District & Ellis Island

➡️Day 4: Cross the Brooklyn Bridge & Explore DUMBO

New York Itinerary Day One: Central Park & Night Time Views

For your first day in New York, we’re going to see some of the city’s top sights and cross off a few bucket list destinations.

Must-See Sights for New York Day One

• Central Park
• The Met
• American Museum of Natural History
• Times Square at night
• Observatory at night

Morning in New York City

Start your New York City morning off with a sweet breakfast and delicious coffee before you make your way to explore one of the most iconic parks in the entire world!

Breakfast & Coffee

It would be a major faux pax to start your first day in New York City without a cup of coffee. 

There is nothing that goes better with New York than a fresh latte or Americano. Except, maybe a good slice of pizza or a bagel with schmear. 

Either way, make sure you get yourself energized for your first big adventure in the city by stopping at Black Press Coffee for a bite of breakfast and a swig of caffeine. 

Black Press Coffee is a chic little café with a mission to offer a welcoming, inclusive, and affirming space where people can enjoy exquisite coffee and exceptional service.

It’s also conveniently located just a block away from our first stop — Central Park!

Black Press Coffee: 274 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023

A Morning in Central Park

Whether you’re visiting New York in the winter, spring, summer, or fall, Central Park has got to be one of the first places in the city you stop by. It’s gorgeous year-round, and there is always something to do. 

Central Park is an absolute icon and beloved landmark in New York City. It’s one of the most romanticized aspects of NYC. And one of the only places that lives up to its magical reputation.

Here are some of the highlights in Central Park to see on your first visit:

• Alice in Wonderland Statue
• Belvedere Castle
• Umpire Rock
• Bow Bridge
• Gapstow Bridge
• Bethesda Terrace and Fountain

This park is sprawling, covering a vast 843 acres. So, don’t get lost, and remember you’ve got a lot of ground to cover in just 4 days.

---

---

Afternoon

Once you’ve completed your Central Park exploration, I recommend venturing into a museum. 

New York City is full of museums. There is no way you’ll be able to see all of them in one trip. But if you plan your time wisely, you can fit two into one day. And two of the world’s most famous museums happen to be super close to Central Park!

The Metropolitan Museum of Art

Located inside Central Park, is your first museum stop, The Metropolitan Museum of Art. 

Commonly referred to as The Met, this iconic museum has been in operation for over 150 years. It’s not only one of the best museums in New York but one of the most famous museums in the world! And it’s definitely worth a visit during your 4-day trip to New York City. 

Boasting an extraordinary collection of over 2 million art pieces spanning an impressive 5,000 years, The Met reigns as the largest museum in the United States. It also ranks as the world’s fifth-largest. With an annual average of 6 million visitors, The Met holds the title of the most frequented museum in New York City. 

Be sure to see these unmissable gems while meandering the museum:

• Emanuel Leutze’s Washington Crossing the Delaware
• Vincent van Gogh’s Self Portrait with a Straw Hat (he’s my favorite artist, by the way)
• Monet’s Bridge over a Pond of Water Lilies
• Jacques-Louis David’s The Death of Socrates
• And Ancient Egypt’s The Temple of Dundur 

You could honestly fill up your entire New York itinerary with 4 whole days at The Met alone, but even just a few hours here is enough to make this museum a highlight of your New York adventure.

The Met: 1000 5th Ave, New York, NY 10028

Where To Eat Near Central Park in the Afternoon

To make the most of your time, I recommend eating at one of the dining options inside The Met. 

The museum offers several dining choices at a range of prices, from the budget-friendly Great Hall Balcony Café to the luxurious Balcony Lounge and The Met Dining Room. 

They also have two mid-tier restaurants: The Cantor Roof Garden Bar and Petrie Court Café, the second of which is located in a stunning sculpture gallery.

American Museum of Natural History

When you’re finished exploring all the exquisite artwork at The Met, take a stroll through Central Park to the American Museum of Natural History. The Museum of Natural History is located directly across from The Met on the west side of the park on 79th Street.

With an annual reception of 5 million visitors and its comprehensive exploration of every facet of the natural world, the American Museum of Natural History stands as one of the world’s preeminent natural history museums.

Upon entering, guests are greeted by two colossal dinosaur skeletons. From there, you can explore the impressive permanent exhibitions or delve into intriguing rotating displays.

Whether you’re drawn to the Planetarium, dinosaur fossils, Egyptian art, the Winter Butterfly Conservatory, or a plethora of other attractions, this museum offers something to captivate every visitor.

American Museum of Natural History: 200 Central Park West, New York, NY 10024

Evening

By this point, the sun should be setting on your first day in New York, which means it’s the perfect time to make your way to NYC’s most famous district — Times Square!

Times Square (Optional)

I’ll be honest with you: Times Square is not my favorite part of New York. In fact, it’s my least favorite part of the city. BUT, I definitely think that you should visit the district at least once because it’s an iconic part of American culture.

Thanks to an uncountable number of movies and TV shows, Times Square is one of the most famous aspects of NYC, which makes it an essential stop for most first-time visitors. But like many things, the reality is pretty different from what’s on screen.

Times Square can be overwhelming. And it’s perpetually inundated with tourists, particularly in the evening when the lights start to shine. You’ll inevitably find yourself jostling through the crowds while wafts of marijuana smoke and piss fill your nostrils.

But don’t let me deter you from stopping by. You should still experience the district firsthand. I’m just trying to curb your expectations.

But if it’s not a bucket list stop for you — and you won’t feel any FOMO if you skip it — then feel free to do that and go to the next destination on the itinerary.

Where To Eat In New York City in the Evening

From Times Square, make your way to Urbanspace Vanderbilt for dinner. Food halls are an iconic aspect of New York City’s food scene. This one is conveniently located near both Times Square and the Empire State Building — our last stop on Day 1’s itinerary. 

Food halls are a foodie’s dream. They offer a wide array of culinary delights that include both street-food classics and establishments led by renowned chefs.

Urbanspace Vanderbilt is a massive 12,000-square-foot permanent establishment featuring a 200-seat food court. 

The hall features delectable offerings like La Palapa’s tantalizing tacos and Roberta’s wood-fired pizzas. In addition to these classics, the food hall introduces newcomers to its vibrant culinary landscape, such as Ovenly, Toby’s Estate Coffee, and the vegetarian pop-up, Two Tbsp.

Urbanspace Vanderbilt: 230 Park Ave, New York, NY 10169

Touch the Sky From the Top of the Empire State Building

What is a visit to New York without seeing New York’s most famous building?

A visit to the Empire State Building, or even simply passing by its towering presence, is an absolute must during your four days in New York!

There’s a reason I’ve saved the Empire State Building as the last excursion on Day 1. While many itineraries might have you zooming up to the top of the observatory during the day, you are going to get much more beautiful and unique photos of New York City at night. Just imagine the millions of twinkling lights shining against a black sky!

The Empire State Building: 20 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001

New York Itinerary Day Two: The High Line & Broadway, Baby

Day two in New York is going to take you to a few of New York’s underrated gems and some fantastic photo locations. You’ll end the day with one of the city’s most unforgettable experiences — a Broadway show!

Must-See Sights for New York Day Two

• Highline and Little Island Parks
• New York Public Library
• Saint Patrick’s Cathedral
• Broadway

Morning

Start your morning off the New York way with a bagel, coffee, and some iconic New York experiences.

Breakfast & Coffee Near the High Line

Remember how I said bagels and coffee are synonymous with New York? Well, we’re going to get you the full New York experience by grabbing breakfast at Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys near the High Line. It’s convenient because the High Line is the first stop on Day Two’s itinerary.

Kossar’s is located near the 30th Street entrance of the High Line. It’s been serving fresh New York-style bagels since 1939. They’ve got tons of toppings to choose from, taste fantastic, and go superb with a cup of coffee. 

Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys: 536 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001

The High Line & Little Island Parks

After grabbing breakfast, head over to the 30th Street entrance to the High Line in Chelsea, New York. 

On your way, feel free to stop at The Vessel. This honeycomb-shaped structure is currently closed (and has been since 2021). But the ground floor is open and accessible to the public. It’s a spectacular spot to snap some cool pictures.

The High Line

The High Line is just one example of the potential of urban landscaping. It’s a long and narrow park that was transformed from an old railway line.

The entire park is about a mile and a half in length. As you walk through this unusual linear path, you’ll pass stunning urban landscaping, murals, and art installations along the way.  

The High Line ends at Gansevoort Street at the Whitney Museum of American Art. Certainly feel free to stop in here, especially if you’re a museum aficionado. This museum is dedicated exclusively to showcasing the art of American artists from the 20th century and the contemporary era. However, for the point of this itinerary, the Whitney Museum is an optional activity. The next official stop actually being the Little Island Park across the street from the High Line.

Little Island Park

The Little Island Park lives up to its name as it’s a small, human-made island park built on a raised platform design. It’s adorned with vibrant flower beds and often hosts performances at a waterfront amphitheater.

This park is another terrific place for pictures and to see the Manhattan skyline. On a clear day, you can even catch a glimpse of the Statue of Liberty.

The High Line 30th Street Entrance: You can find this entrance near the corner of 30th Street and 10th Avenue, next to the Wells Fargo Bank.

Little Island Park: Pier 55 in Hudson River Park at, W 13th St, New York, NY 10014

Afternoon

Grab an early lunch at the famous Chelsea Market food hall, then make your way to Midtown to experience New York’s history.

Where To Eat Near The High Line in the Afternoon

After you’re done at the High Line and Little Island, head over to Chelsea Market to grab a bite to eat.

Chelsea Market is a renowned food haven. It seamlessly blends a delightful assortment of restaurants, shops, and food vendors under one roof. With an impressive lineup of 35 vendors, it’s a culinary treasure trove waiting to dazzle your taste buds. 

Among the highlights at Chelsea Market are the heavenly matcha creations from freshly baked donuts from the Doughnuttery, delectable tacos served by Los Tacos No. 1, a treasure trove of spices at Spices and Tease, and an array of unique souvenirs available at Pearl River Mart.

Overflowing with an array of boutiques and food stalls, Chelsea Market is a foodie’s wonderland. Los Tacos No. 1 is often celebrated for serving some of the finest tacos in New York. 

Chelsea Market: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011

The Flatiron District

The Flatiron building in New York gets its name because it’s literally triangular shaped like an iron. For fans of famous architecture or anyone wanting to grab a killer Instagram photo, this is a must-stop location. Though, you should know that the building itself is not open to the public. 

After you’ve snapped your shot, I recommend lingering in the area to explore the Flatiron District’s diverse surroundings. I’d recommend exploring the nearby Madison Square Park, which foodies might enjoy since it’s the birthplace of the original Shake Shack. 

There’s also Eataly, a mecca for Italian food enthusiasts. The rooftop bar also offers a trendy spot for a drink.

Also near the Flatiron District, I highly recommend the Museum of Sex, which offers a fun twist on classic museums and features a hidden carnival game room in the basement.

For fans of the Friends TV show, the Friends Experience is conveniently located near the Flatiron Building, offering a unique and non-traditional attraction to explore.

New York Public Library: Stephen A. Schwarzman Building

From the Flatiron District, make your way back up to Midtown to 6th Ave and 42nd Street. Here, you’ll find Bryant Park and the New York Public Library. 

Bryant Park is a little green oasis tucked between buildings in the very center of Manhattan. It’s so charming and feels like a little bit of Paris right here in New York City. Feel free to cut through the park on your way to the library.

A visit to the New York Public Library: Stephen A. Schwarzman Building is a must for everyone at least once in their lifetime. It was one of the very first stops I made when I first came to the city, and I recommend it to anyone who is visiting. 

When it first opened in 1911, the New York Public Library set a record as the largest marble building ever constructed in the United States. The monumental undertaking, spanning 16 years, was indeed a remarkable feat, and the grand opening witnessed an impressive turnout of over 50,000 people. 

Exploring the library is fun, but I’d also recommend you bring a book or notebook so you can access the Rose Reading Room. They only let people planning to do work enter the room unless you join the guided tour.

The Rose Room’s architectural grandeur, with its stunning design and soaring ceilings, creates an inspiring and serene atmosphere encouraging focus and contemplation. Moreover, the Rose Reading Room stands as a historic symbol of knowledge and intellectual pursuit in the heart of New York City.

New York Public Library: Stephen A. Schwarzman Building: 476 5th Ave, New York, NY 10018

Saint Patrick’s Cathedral 

When you exit the library, you’ll find yourself on Fifth Avenue. As you make your way north up the road, you’ll eventually come across Saint Patrick’s Cathedral, another architectural wonder in New York City.

Situated just off Fifth Avenue, this Neo-Gothic masterpiece has been captivating passersby since its completion in 1879. It took 21 years to construct, partly due to a hiatus during the Civil War, and now receives over 5 million visitors annually.

When visiting, please be mindful of the dress code, which requires respectful attire. Avoid exposed shoulders or short shorts.

The cathedral’s allure lies not only in its architectural beauty but also in the striking contrast it presents against the sharp modern concrete and glass structures surrounding it.

Saint Patrick’s Cathedral: 5th Ave, New York, NY 10022

Shopping on Fifth Avenue

After drinking in the gothic beauty of this historic church, you might want to spend some time wandering Fifth Avenue, especially if you love shopping. 

Fifth Avenue in New York City is an exceptional shopping destination renowned for its extensive array of luxury boutiques and department stores featuring high-end fashion and exclusive items. 

Evening

Treat yourself to a delicious dinner before experiencing an iconic New York evening by catching a Broadway show and then grabbing drinks at a rooftop bar.

Where To Eat In Midtown in the Evening

If you’ve hung around Fifth Avenue, then you’re in the heart of Midtown and are surrounded by a plethora of options to choose from for dinner. In this part of town, you’ve got a choice of any type of food for any type of price, from a snack from a food truck to the delicacies of an upscale restaurant. 

However, since you’re about to spend your evening going out to a Broadway show, I recommend starting the night somewhere classy like Fig & Olive.

Fig & Olive is an upscale restaurant and bar offering seasonal Mediterranean cuisine crafted with an array of artisanal flavored olive oils.

Fig & Olive: 10 E 52nd St, New York, NY 10022

Catch a Broadway Show

I highly recommend budgeting for at least one Broadway show during your 4-day stay in New York City. And, just so you know, it’s probably not as expensive as you might think!

There are lots of ways to lower the cost of your Broadway tickets or even get seats for free! I’ve created a small guide at the end of this blog outlining the different ways to save on show tickets. 

As for what to see while you’re in town, the New York Theatre District has plenty of options to choose from. From showstoppers like Hamilton or Wicked to meme-created musicals like Shucked to musicals based on movies like Mean Girls, there’s truly a show for every mood.

After Show Drinks at a Roof Top Bar (optional)

This one is optional, depending on if you’re a night owl or if you would rather get some rest after two exciting days exploring one of the greatest cities in the world. 

But if you’re up for it, I recommend checking out a rooftop bar around Times Square. You’ll be in the area anyway after the show, and it’s one of the coolest ways to experience New York nightlife culture.

Here are a few rooftop bars to try out:

• Castell Rooftop Lounge
• Dear Irving on Hudson
• Bar 54 at Hyatt Centric Times Square

These rooftop terraces provide a wonderful chance to savor delicious food and beverages. They also deliver stunning panoramic views, encompassing the vibrant Times Square and, in most instances, the entire New York City skyline.

New York Itinerary Day Three: The Financial District & Ellis Island 

Today, you’re exploring the heart of Manhattan’s Financial District and the historic immigrant gateway at Ellis Island.

Must-See Sights for New York Day Three

• 9/11 Memorial Museum
• Wall Street
• Ellis Island & Statue of Liberty

Morning

Fuel up on caffeine and something yummy because today’s the day you visit New York’s most iconic site.

Where To Eat Near the Financial District in the Morning

Blue Bottle Coffee is an upscale and trendy café in the Financial District offering amazing views of Ground Zero and the World Trade Center. 

I recommend trying their oat milk latte and grabbing a delicious pastry before beginning your exploration of Lower Manhattan and the Financial District.

Blue Bottle Coffee: 150 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10007 (located in Westfield World Trade Center)

Financial District

A visit to New York’s Financial District promises a mix of reverent remembrance, striking architecture, and a dash of history. Here, you’ll find popular New York attractions to fit into your itinerary during your 4 days in the city, including the Oculus, the 9/11 Museum and Memorial, and Wall Street.

The Oculus is a unique train station that emerged in the aftermath of September 11th. Beyond its role as an NYC transportation hub, the Oculus houses an entire shopping mall and even a bustling farmers market.

While in the area, take time to explore the 9/11 Memorial Museum, a touching tribute to the events of that fateful day. 

Admission is free on Monday evenings from 5:30 p.m. to 7 p.m. So, if Day 3 of your New York itinerary falls on a Monday, and the 9/11 Memorial Museum is a must-do for you, then you might want to consider flipping the morning and afternoon activities to take advantage of free admission.

The lines to enter the museum can be incredibly lengthy, so I highly recommend obtaining the C3 pass if you intend to visit — it allows you to bypass the wait. You can also check out my guide to the C3 and other New York City attraction passes to determine which pass is best for your vacation. 

Whether or not you decide to explore the 9/11 Museum, I still recommend taking a moment to pay your respects at the 9/11 Memorial. Standing in the shadow of the One World Trade Center, the 9/11 Memorial showcases cascading waterfalls, a symbol of remembrance, with the names of victims etched in stone.

Additionally, the Financial District offers a wealth of other attractions, including the iconic Charging Bull and the Fearless Girl statues. This is also where you’ll find another of New York’s historic churches, Trinity Church.

A stroll down Wall Street (so named because there used to be a wall on this street) immerses you in the heart of financial history, while glimpses of the New York Stock Exchange provide a window into the world of global finance. 

Afternoon

After you’ve seen everything you want to see in the Financial District, grab a bite to eat for lunch at one of New York’s oldest taverns (it’s more than 260 years old!). But don’t take too long because you’ll want to make sure you schedule plenty of time to spend at the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island.

Where To Eat In Lower Manhattan in the Afternoon

For lunch, try Fraunces Tavern, a tavern so old that George Washington once headquartered there. 

This charming pub has been a fixture since 1762 and is situated in the middle of the historical district of Lower Manhattan. It’s only a couple of blocks away from the Charging Bull statue and is nestled in a neighborhood filled with a variety of restaurants in case the tavern doesn’t suit your fancy. 

But if you do choose to go to Fraunces Tavern, try their Pear and Arugula Salad. As you enjoy your meal, let your imagination wander to the distant past and imagine those who might have sat in your same seat over 250 years ago.

Fraunces Tavern: 54 Pearl St, New York, NY 10004

The Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and the Hard Hat Tour

It’s a funny fact that most native New Yorkers haven’t been to Ellis Island. But that shouldn’t stop you from taking the ferry over and seeing this majestic green woman in the flesh… er, copper. 

Today, the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration unveils the stories of these newcomers and the challenges they faced when arriving in the States. Explore the restored Great Hall, where hopeful souls were processed, and take a moment to reflect on the American Immigrant Wall of Honor, adorned with the names of immigrants who passed through. 

Whether you’re tracing your own family’s history or simply delving into the collective immigrant experience, Ellis Island promises an enlightening chapter in the tapestry of American heritage.

I also highly recommend taking the Ellis Island Hard Hat Tour. It’s a guided 90-minute tour that provides access to specific sections of the expansive Ellis Island Hospital. 

It encompasses areas like the infectious and contagious disease wards, the kitchen, and even the mortuary and autopsy room. 

It’s equal parts historical and spooky and definitely a unique way to spend your trip to Ellis Island.

Evening

The ferry to and from Ellis Island leaves from the very southern tip of Manhattan, called Battery Park. 

If you’ve got some time to spare, then I recommend exploring another one of New York’s green parks and even stopping by the magical SeaGlass Carousel, an exceptional carousel adorned with oversized, shimmering fiberglass fish and illuminated by captivating undersea-themed lighting effects. It’s fun for travelers of any age. 

Then grab a bite to eat and enjoy your second to last night in New York City.

Where To Eat Near Battery Park in the Evening

When you’re ready, head over to Inatteso Pizzabar for dinner. 

This cozy Italian eatery is located just north of the park on the corner of 1st Place and Little W Street. Despite its location in Lower Manhattan, this little pizza bar does not feel like a tourist trap. It’s a contemporary Italian restaurant, complete with a charming patio, where you can indulge in authentic Neapolitan and pan pizzas, along with an array of other well-loved Italian dishes.

Inatteso Pizzabar: 28 West St, New York, NY 10004

Free Night in Manhattan

The last ferry from Ellis Island departs in the early evening, anywhere from 5:15 p.m. to 7 p.m., depending on what time of year you’re visiting (check the current ferry schedule here). 

So, by the time you’ve finished dinner in Lower Manhattan, you’ve likely got a whole night ahead of you. 

I know how exhausting three full days in a brand-new city can be. So, if you’d rather spend the evening resting at your accommodations, I wouldn’t blame you. But if you’re a night owl, then take advantage of being in New York by going out on the town and enjoying the NYC nightlife.

I’d recommend checking out some of these nightlife locations on the Lower East Side: 

• Gugu Room
• Lullaby
• Las’ Lap
• The Flower Shop
• Clandestino

The Lower East Side includes an array of nighttime activities, from cocktail lounges to dive bars, taverns, and clubs. No matter what your style is, NYC has got you covered. 

If the bar and club scene isn’t your thing, you can also check out my guide to the 72 Best Things To Do In NYC At Night.

New York Itinerary Day Four: Exploring Brooklyn

Up to this point, your entire New York itinerary has stayed within the borders of Manhattan, but we’re going to mix it up a bit for Day 4. Today, you’re heading to Brooklyn, New York’s trendiest borough. 

Must-See Sights for New York Day Four

• Brooklyn Bridge
• DUMBO
• Brooklyn Museum
• Williamsburg

Morning

Not everyone can say they’ve walked across the Brooklyn Bridge, but after today, you’ll be able to add it to your book of travel adventures.

Where To Eat Near the Brooklyn Bridge in the Morning

Today, you’re going to walk into Brooklyn by crossing over the Brooklyn Bridge. So, I recommend fueling up at About Coffee, conveniently located just a couple blocks away from the bridge entrance, before beginning your trek.

This fun little coffee shop is such a vibe, has super nice people, and serves delicious coffee. Grab a latte and a croissant to go, and then make your way over to the Brooklyn Bridge.

About Coffee: 222 Front St, New York, NY 10038

Cross the Brooklyn Bridge From Manhattan Into Brooklyn

Crossing the Brooklyn Bridge is an essential experience for anyone exploring New York City — and it’s totally free! 

This historic bridge once held the title of the world’s longest suspension bridge. While it lost that crown long ago (and isn’t even in the top 10 anymore), it still holds the marker for being one of the oldest bridges in the country, with construction having been completed in 1883.

Crossing the Brooklyn Bridge is a scenic one-mile stroll delivering some of the most breathtaking views of the city. 

This is definitely an activity you’ll want to fit into your New York itinerary during your 4 days in the city. To make the most out of crossing the Brooklyn Bridge, make sure to arrive early to avoid the crowds. This bridge can get pretty busy with both tourists and commuters. 

Take your time as you cross the bridge to truly drink in the magnificent views and take all the photos your camera roll can handle. This is an activity worth preserving.

Brooklyn Bridge Manhattan Side Entrance: Located on Centre Street, across the street from City Hall Park and nestled between Park Row and the David N. Dinkins Manhattan Municipal Building.

Explore DUMBO

After your stroll across the Brooklyn Bridge, take some time to explore the captivating neighborhood of DUMBO, an acronym that stands for “down under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass.”

If getting Instagram-worthy pictures is important to you — whether you actually post them or keep them for your own private memories — your first stop should be the intersection of Waters Street and Washinton Street. This iconic photo spot captures a fantastic picture of the Manhattan Bridge with the Empire State Building framed perfectly in the center. 

Other things to do in DUMBO include meandering along cobblestone streets, unwinding on the picturesque lawns of Brooklyn Bridge Park, or ambling down the scenic piers. 

You can also take a leisurely walk up the Squibb Bridge to the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, which offers stunning views of the New York skyline. 

Pebble Beach and Jane’s Carosaul are also popular things to do in DUMBO.

Afternoon

First, have lunch at a true New York hole-in-the-wall. Then, explore ancient history at your last New York museum visit of this trip.

Where To Eat Near DUMBO in the Afternoon

Noodle Pudding is a true hidden gem that even local New Yorkers have never heard of. 

This place doesn’t bother with a website or a sign. Instead, it’s a hole-in-the-wall restaurant that’s quietly nestled on a peaceful side street. Here, there is no need for reservations, in fact, they don’t even take them. Just pop on in and enjoy.

The atmosphere at Noodle Pudding oozes old-school charm, complete with big front windows that swing open to welcome the summer breeze. And if you’re in the mood for a martini paired with a plate of colossal lasagna, their bar is the place to be. 

Please note that this place is cash only, so be sure to stop at the ATM on your way over. 

Noodle Pudding: 38 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Brooklyn Museum

A trip to the Brooklyn Museum is a cultural whirlwind through time and space, and it’s an absolute must on your New York itinerary when spending 4 days in the city. Besides, you started your trip by visiting a museum, so why not end it at one as well?

At the Brooklyn Museum, you’ll find a treasure trove of art and cultural artifacts from various corners of the world and throughout history. From the captivating allure of ancient Egyptian relics to cutting-edge contemporary art installations, the museum’s eclectic collection has something for everyone. 

It’s a vibrant kaleidoscope of human history and creativity that’s sure to leave you inspired. So whether you’re a dedicated art lover or just up for an enriching experience, the Brooklyn Museum is where captivating stories come to life!

Brooklyn Museum: 200 Eastern Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11238

Evening

Celebrate the completion of your very first New York City vacation with some delicious Thai food, then party it up like a true New Yorker in fashionable Williamsburg.

Where To Eat In Brooklyn in the Evening

At a casual glance, Kru might come across as your typical “cool” Williamsburg restaurant. Williamsburg is known for being especially trendy and artsy and Kru fits right in with its dimly lit ambiance, dark walls, and subtle yet charming decor featuring botanical illustrations and delicate stemware. 

However, this is no ordinary trendy spot. Kru is all about reinventing age-old Thai recipes, and every plate that emerges from the kitchen is an absolute sensation. It’s the perfect choice to celebrate the end of your first visit to New York City.

Kru: 190 N 14th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Experience Nightlife in Williamsburg

When the sun sets in Williamsburg, the neighborhood transforms into a nightlife wonderland. 

This dynamic corner of Brooklyn is famous for its thriving nocturnal scene, where live music venues, cozy bars, and lively clubs await. 

Whether you’re in the mood for…

• A craft cocktail in an intimate speakeasy
• Dancing the night away to the tunes of local bands
• Or simply enjoying a laid-back evening at a rooftop bar with friends…

Williamsburg has it all. The atmosphere here is electric, and the locals are friendly and welcoming, making it easy to strike up conversations and find your rhythm in the city that never sleeps. 

Hip, artsy, and trendy, Williamsburg shows a whole nother side to New York than Manhattan. So don’t miss the opportunity to close out your 4 days in New York with a bang by celebrating the excitement of Williamsburg after dark.

Where To Stay In New York?

Navigating the expanse of New York City can feel like a whirlwind, especially when it comes to choosing the perfect place to lay your head at night. 

As a fervent advocate for crafting a trip tailored to your unique needs, I won’t lay claim to the one-size-fits-all “best” spot for your stay. However, based on the activities in this New York itinerary, I’d recommend looking into neighborhoods like Lower Manhattan, SoHo, or Greenwich Village, with Lower Manhattan likely being the most convenient location.

Where to stay in Lower Manhattan

Lower Manhattan is a convenient location for first-time visitors in New York as it’s not too far from most of the excursions on this itinerary.

📍Budget-Friendly Option in Lower Manhattan: The Madison LES Hotel

📍Midrange Option in Lower Manhattan: The Artezen

📍Luxury Option in Lower Manhattan: The Ludlow Hotel 

(P.S. Check out my Guide to Lower Manhattan for more tips and insights on this vibrant neighborhood.)

Additional Options for Where to Stay During Your 4 Days in New York

Some hotels feature awesome perks, like complimentary bicycle rentals to explore the city. If that’s something you’re into, take a peek at The Jane Hotel in charming Greenwich Village, The Maritime Hotel in the heart of Chelsea, or the Arlo Midtown, tucked away in the vibrant Hell’s Kitchen.

If traditional hotels don’t fit your vibe, I totally understand. Explore numerous private home options in New York City, available through VRBO. Not only can this often (though not always) be a more budget-friendly choice, but home rentals also deliver that cozy, home-away-from-home feeling.

How To Get To Midtown From the Airport

New York City is served by three airports, and unfortunately, none of them are exactly conveniently located. But fret not, because New York is abundant in public transportation, specifically, taxis, Uber/Lyft, and the subway. 

Here’s how to get to your accommodations from each airport:

From JFK

John F. Kennedy International (JFK), the primary international airport serving NYC, is located in Queens. To make your way into the city, you can hop on the AirTrain to connect to the subway system. 

Or if you prefer a more direct route, you can catch a taxi that offers a flat rate to various locations in Manhattan. Or book an Uber/Lyft, which can sometimes be cheaper than taxis.

From La Guardia

LaGuardia (LGA), widely favored for United States domestic flights, is also located in Queens. You can easily access the heart of NYC from LaGuardia by hopping on a bus that connects to the central parts of the city. And, of course, a taxi, Uber, or Lyft are also options.

From Newark

Newark Liberty International (EWR), while situated in New Jersey, is surprisingly straightforward to reach if you’re staying in Manhattan. Trains conveniently run between Penn Station and the airport, and you can also opt for the Newark Airport Express buses departing from midtown for hassle-free transit. 

I wouldn’t recommend a taxi, Uber, or Lyft from this airport though as that is likely a much more expensive option.

Getting Around New York

New York is one of the easiest cities to get around because there is no need for a rental car. Most attractions within a neighborhood are within walking distance and nearly everything is accessible by train or bus. 

Here’s more info on how to get around in New York City:

Take the subway

The New York City subway is an integral part of the Big Apple experience. Personally, I’m a big fan of taking the subway whenever possible because it’s easy, cheap, and relatively quick. But it can also get pretty crowded, especially during rush hour. 

It’s also not the most comfortable mode of transportation. Subway stations can get hot and muggy year-round. While this isn’t such a drag in the summer when you’re wearing cooler clothing anyway, it can be a major pain in the winter. You’ll be sweating through your coat because it will be freezing outside but freaking hot inside the subway stations.

Still, for the price of $2.90 a ride, the price of the New York City subway can’t be beat.

Walk on Foot

Well, there is one mode of transportation that can beat the subway’s cheap fare, and that’s walking.

Now, you won’t be able to walk everywhere during your trip — after all, New York is vast. However, by choosing to walk whenever feasible, you’ll not only save money but also get the chance to explore more of the city. 

Surprisingly, in certain areas, particularly during rush hours, you might be astonished to discover that the time difference between driving, taking the subway, and walking is pretty minimal anyway.

Call an Uber or Lyft

Uber and Lyft are convenient for getting around New York City, especially if you’re traveling in a large group and can split the cost. While a ride-share might cost $30-$50, if you’re in a group of 4 or more, the price might be worth the time and energy you’ll save by not taking the subway.

Flag a Taxi

If you truly want to have your New York City movie moment, then you always have the option of flagging a bright yellow taxi while on the streets of Times Square.

To determine if a taxi is ready for pickup, check that the light on top of the cab is lit up. If it is, then the taxi is available. The best way to pay for a taxi is with a credit card.

Best Time of Year to Book Your New York 4-Day Itinerary

Honestly, there’s no wrong time to visit New York. Winter, spring, summer, or fall, there is always something awesome going on in New York City.

Spring

Spring in New York unveils a vibrant burst of color, with cherry blossoms, magnolias, tulips, and more blooming throughout the city and her many, many parks. The delightful weather and fewer crowds make it an ideal time to visit.

Summer

Summer in NYC is the perfect time for nightlife and outdoor activities. Explore the plethora of rooftop bars, al fresco dining spots, parkside movie screenings, kayaking adventures, dinner cruises, Governors Island escapades, and a host of other summer festivities. 

The downside, of course, is the sweltering heat and humidity.

Fall

Autumn in New York ranks as one of my preferred seasons, but I’m rather partial to fall in any location since it’s my favorite time of year. But I’m sure you’d agree with me (and Meg Ryan’s character in You’ve Got Mail) that fall in New York is spectacular, in part thanks to the city’s breathtaking fall foliage. Not to mention, the weather is delightful, and the streets are less congested than in summer.

Winter

The holiday season in New York is an exceptionally popular time to explore the city, and it’s easy to see why. The city transforms into a magical wonderland adorned with dazzling lights, festive decorations, Christmas trees, and charming Christmas-themed eateries. Not to mention, Hollywood has done a damn fine job romanticizing New York during the holidays. 

This time of year is definitely one of my top choices. But keep in mind that it can get very chilly and considerably more crowded.

Also keep in mind that Christmas is the exception, not the rule. New York in winter is not really that much fun. Once the holiday decorations come down, all you’re left with is cold chill, and grumpy locals. But if that doesn’t faze you, then you might want to take advantage of winter deals aiming to entice tourists with budget-friendly winter rates.

Tips for Visiting New York City for First Time

Now that we’ve created a thorough New York Itinerary for your 4 days in the city, let’s go over a few tips for first-time NYC visitors.

Pay Attention To What Airport You Book Your Flight From

As mentioned above, NYC has three different airports, and they’re all in different parts of the city. In the case of Newark, it’s not even in New York state and is actually about an hour’s drive away in New Jersey. So just make sure you double and triple-check which airport you booked your flight from so you can plan accordingly.

Take Advantage of the 7-Day Unlimited Ride Metro Card

It’s highly likely you’ll find yourself relying on the subway for your citywide travels. The Metro pass is an absolute game-changer. It offers unlimited subway access for an entire week at the mere cost of $34.

Opting for a single ride without the unlimited pass can quickly become costly, as one-way tickets for local trains cost $2.90 per journey. So, investing in the Metro pass is a wise and wallet-friendly choice!

Be Prepared To Wait In Lines

With a staggering 63 million annual visitors, New York City is undeniably a bustling hub of activity. It’s the number one most visited city in the United States. 

The downside of this vibrant tourism scene is that popular attractions and eateries often draw enormous crowds, resulting in lengthy queues. Pretend you’re at Disney and be ready for some wait times!

Swap Style for Comfort, at Least When It Comes to Shoes

You’re going to walk during your trip to New York City. You’re going to walk, a lot. It’s another thing a New York trip has in common with a Disney trip. You’ll probably clock 10+ miles in a single day, so be sure to pack comfortable walking shoes. Seriously, your feet will thank you later.

Step to the Side if Stopping on the Sidewalk

New Yorkers are famous for their fast-paced and often direct demeanor, especially on the bustling streets of the city. It’s not rudeness; it’s just the result of their hectic schedules and the perpetual rush of the city. So, if you find yourself needing to pause for directions, particularly in a crowded location, it’s a good practice (and polite) to step aside and avoid obstructing the busy flow of foot traffic.

Bring Cash (Just in Case)

You might be surprised to find that many bars and restaurants in New York City operate on a cash-only basis. There are even a few cash-only spots highlighted in this itinerary. So it’s wise to come prepared with some cash on hand!

Research Restaurants and Attractions Before Going

New York City’s restaurant scene is constantly evolving. With new restaurants opening daily, and others undergoing changes, it can be challenging to keep up. I highly recommend checking out recent restaurant reviews to stay informed about the latest updates and ensure that every meal you enjoy during your 4 days in New York lives up to your expectations.

Visiting New York: FAQs

At last, let’s dive into the final section of this New York Itinerary: 4 Days guide — the Frequently Asked Questions.

Is 4 Days Enough To See New York?

Honestly, no. But that’s the same as any short trip to any big city in the world. There’s so much to see here in New York that I haven’t seen it all even after over a year of exploring the city. My sister hasn’t seen it all even after 5 years of living here. And our friends who were born and raised in NYC and have spent nearly 30 years here haven’t seen all that New York has to offer. 

Instead of trying to cover everything during your 4 days in New York, try looking at your trip as a New York Sample Platter. This is your introduction to the city and you can always come back to see the rest. 

So, maximize your introduction to the city and let NYC leave you wanting more for the next time you come to visit.

How Much Does It Cost To Stay in New York for 4 Days?

The cost of your New York vacation is going to range drastically depending on the type of activities you do and what your style of travel is.

According to Budget Your Trip, the average New York vacation costs $316 per day and includes everything from accommodations to food to activities. But you can easily play with that number to match your needs. 

The total cost for all the activities on this 4-day New York itinerary is about $400. That does not include the price of food, transportation, souvenirs, or accommodation. 

Also, keep in mind that this is just a rough estimate. Admission prices are subject to change, and the cost could be higher or lower depending on the exact details of your trip. For example, a Broadway ticket can vary in price from $50 to $250 depending on the show you’re seeing and where you’re sitting. Prices may change depending on the time of year or even the day of the week you’re visiting.

Make sure to do your research before your trip and create a budget that matches your needs.

Should You Get a NYC Attraction Pass?

New York has several attraction passes meant to save visitors time and money while exploring the city. 

Given your limited 4 days in New York City, I wouldn’t advise going for the standard NYC CityPASS. Priced at $136 per person, it offers access to six attractions within a 9-day window. You likely won’t have the time to fully enjoy all six attractions in just 4 days.

On the other hand, the New York City C3 Pass is a more practical option. Priced at $96 per person, it grants access to three attractions within a 9-day timeframe.

The C3 Pass could be worth it if you plan on visiting at least three of the following locations:

• Empire State Building (regular admission is $44/person)
• Top of the Rock (regular admission is $40/person)
• Ferry Access to the Statue of Liberty (regular admission is $24.50/person)
• 9/11 Museum (regular admission is $24/person)
• American Museum of Natural History (regular admission is $25/person)
• The Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) (regular admission is $25/person)

Plus using the C3 Pass allows you to skip the line at popular attractions, saving you invaluable time.

What’s the Cheapest Time To Go to New York?

The low season in New York falls between January and March. 

This period comes with winter weather and the potential for unpredictable snowstorms. If you’re accustomed to chilly winters, it can be an ideal time to plan your visit. 

During these months, you’ll find more affordable hotel rates, less crowded museums, and the opportunity to grab budget-friendly Broadway tickets.

How Long Should I Stay in New York for My First Time?

For first-time visitors, you should plan to stay in New York for at least 4 days. This is enough time to experience a “sample platter” of NYC. In other words, it’s enough time to see the biggest attractions and whet your appetite for your next trip to the city.

Of course, if you have the ability to spend longer in the city, a full week in New York would be the perfect amount of time to see all the major attractions and historical sites.

What Area Should I Stay In During My 4-Day New York Trip?

When visiting New York for the first time, you’ll be spending most of your time in Manhattan. So the best place to stay, location-wise, is in Lower Manhattan, Midtown, or somewhere in between. 

Accommodation in New York City for a 4-day stay can be pricey, especially when opting for a hotel. You’ll likely find the best rates and central location staying somewhere like Greenwich Village or SoHo.

Legitimate Ways To Save Money on Broadway Tickets

Broadway tickets can get expensive. Here are a few ways you can save:

For legitimate last-minute discounts, make a trip to the TKTS booth at Duffy Square in Times Square. Although lines may be lengthy, you can check out a live webcam feed before heading there.

If you’re open to the idea of sitting separately from your group, try for rush tickets. These are tickets that are sold on the same day of the show from whatever seats are left over or seats that become randomly available. You can buy rush tickets directly at the ticket window, or online through platforms like TodayTix.

Consider testing your luck with the ticket lottery system for a chance to win free tickets. To enter the lottery, simply visit the website of the show you’d like to see and locate the lottery button. Big productions like Hamilton and The Lion King have lotteries and are known to offer extraordinary experiences.

Opt for a Broadway show on a weekday rather than the weekend. Weekends tend to be busier and more expensive, as people have more availability. If your New York itinerary allows flexibility during your 4 days in the city, target weekdays for your theater outing.

Final Thoughts: New York 4-Day Itinerary

In The City That Never Sleeps, four days might seem like a mere blink, but with this carefully crafted itinerary, you’ll make the most of every moment. 

From iconic landmarks to hidden gems, and world-class dining to delightful surprises on each corner, New York City promises a whirlwind of unforgettable experiences. 

Whether you covered all the attractions listed in this New York itinerary over your 4 days in the city or left a few gems for next time, you’re bound to depart with a heart full of memories and I have no doubt you’ll be back again soon. In the meantime, check out the resources below for more help planning your trip to NYC.

Additional Resources:

Also planning on visiting Brooklyn? Check out my guide on the Best Places to Stay in Brooklyn, NYC.

Booking.com